Rediscovering the Forgotten Enlightenment: Pre-Ghazalian Muslim Intellectualism in the Context of Islamic History

• Talha Shafiq

  Author

This research paper addresses the complex concept of the Enlightenment and its profound existence within the classical Islamic intellectual tradition, with a concentrated focus on the seminal pre-Ghazalian era, commonly revered as the “Islamic Golden Age.” The term Enlightenment is conventionally and often exclusively associated with the European philosophical and scientific movements of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, which promoted reason, individualism, and a degree of skepticism towards established religious and political authority. This study, however, fundamentally argues that the Islamic world experienced a distinct, powerful, and endogenous form of intellectual flourishing, which deserves to be recognized as an “Islamic Enlightenment” in its own right, characterized by a deep belief in the power of human reason (‘aql) guided by revelation. The discussion explores the exceptional intellectual achievements of Muslim scholars, philosophers, and scientists during this epoch, emphasizing their foundational contributions across diverse fields, including speculative theology, mathematics, astronomy, and clinical medicine. It highlights the critical, non-negotiable role of rigorous rational inquiry and the proactive, sophisticated engagement with pre-existing Hellenistic, Persian, and Indian intellectual traditions in forging this unparalleled intellectual creativity. Furthermore, the analysis draws attention to a key, differentiating feature: unlike its later European counterpart, the Islamic intellectual movement did not necessitate a conflict between science and religion, instead emphasizing the profound compatibility and complementary nature of rational investigation and religious faith. The paper concludes by tracing the historical factors contributing to the complex decline of these traditions, yet stresses the contemporary imperative to revive and celebrate this lost intellectual heritage of independent reasoning (ijtihad).

• pdf

Copyright (c) 2025 Talha Shafiq (Author)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.